Welcome to the official website of Jim Brown - NEW COLUMNS appear each Monday!
This site is part of Brown Publications and The Lisburn Press
You are visiting my site on: June 19, 2024

National Political Life Left for Bobby Jindal?

Jim Brown Audio Player
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...


Thursday, July 2, 2009

Linville, North Carolina



That’s the question posed to me by a group of political consultants meeting in Charlotte this week as they tried to ferret out what Republican is a viable contender for the 2012 presidential nomination.  The group felt that under normal circumstances, a presidential effort by current Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal would have been permanently sidelined by what they perceived to be a childish and weak televised response to Pres. Obama’s address to the nation in February.

But that was then. In the past month, the Republican presidential herd has been thinning fast.  First there was Utah Gov. Jon Huntsman who had recently set up a presidential campaign fund. But he surprised a number of fellow Republicans by accepting the President’s offer to make him Ambassador to China.

Then the sexual escapades blew up in national news reports in a double whammy that took out of contention, first Nevada Sen. John Ensign, followed by the bizarre revelations of extramarital activity by Gov. Mark Sanford of South Carolina.  

Sanford had made the Louisiana Governor look like a piker when it came to turning down the millions of dollars on the table in stimulus money authorized by Congress. He admonished the President by postulating: “Since we’re issuing debt to solve a problem that was created by too much debt; since that’s taking place, and since those costs will be borne by the next generation, in fact it is sort of physical child abuse to do what we’re doing.” Sanford made it clear that there should be no spending government money in any unwarranted and inappropriate manner. You can imagine the surprise to hear how the South Carolina Governor spent almost $10,000 of taxpayers’ money to visit his Argentine girlfriend.

By the way, one of the hottest bumper stickers floating around says: “Sanford/Ensign in 2012.”

“I still believe our Republican nominee will be a governor,” said Nick Ayers, executive director of the Republican Governors Association. He also added the nomination could very well go to someone with little name recognition. “When George W. Bush got reelected in 2004, Barack Obama was a state legislator,” Ayers said.

Jindal’s stumblings have given an opening to Mississippi Gov. Haley Barbour who appeared last week in New Hampshire for a party fundraiser.  He also took over as chairman of the Republican Governors Association last week after Sanford step down, and he is off to Iowa next week where the first presidential primary caucuses take place.

Of course any Republican list right now includes Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin. But her family dramas continue to play like a long-running soap opera, and can she ever get beyond the Tina Fey tag that “I can see Russia from my house?”     Last week, a Fox news poll indicated that a majority of Republicans say former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani would likely be the top contender; followed by former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney and former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee. Palin comes in a distant fourth and Jindal is not even on the radar.

With so many of the higher profile governors either being labeled as has beens from the last campaign, or like Jindal have let a golden opportunity go by, lesser-known governors are beginning to test the national political waters. Those in the minor league hoping to ascend to the top-tier include Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty, and Indiana Gov. Mitch Daniels. The Hoosier state chief executive gained national public praise for his commencement speech at Butler University recently where he blasted baby boomers as self-indulgent. He recently won a second term overwhelmingly in a state carried by the President during last year’s election.

My group in Charlotte all agreed that the Republican Party’s  number one objective would be to find a candidate who can address public perceptions that the GOP is both intolerant and irrelevant, not to mention being scandalized by politicians who preach family values while getting caught up in extra marital affairs.

So who is there to lead the charge?  And is there any way that Bobby Jindal can resurrect his national image and be considered a relevant contender for the 2012 presidential nomination?  He did not seem to help his cause in the just completed annual session of the Louisiana Legislature. Newspapers throughout the state by and large have panned any significant accomplishments, and criticized Jindal for his failure to offer strong leadership and specific proposals.

The New Orleans Times Picayune headlined: “Legislative Session a missed Opportunity.”  The Lafayette advertiser bluntly stated that “Leadership missing this Session.” And the Baton Rouge Morning Advocate concluded that “Jindal and legislature took steps backward.”  The Jindal team strategy was based on either cutting or holding the line on state spending. There were few specifics given to legislators that would define the Jindal scenario of a state government reorganization plan or any long-range goals for the state’s future.

If the group were called on to offer some specific advice to Bobby Jindal on how he can reclaim a top-tier spot as a major presidential contender, what would they suggest? Surprisingly, they offered a number of ideas. In their opinion, Jindal has let some golden opportunities pass both him and the state by.

The list is long. Oh, I’ll have it for you.  But with space running out, keep a lookout for next week’s column.  Here’s the challenge for Bobby Jindal.  Is there still national political life after being compared to Mister Rogers?


“Being compared to Mister Rogers is better than some of the other comparisons we’ve had here in the past.” 

          Bobby Jindal

Peace and Justice

Jim Brown

 Jim Brown’s syndicated column appears weekly in numerous newspapers and websites throughout the south.  You can read all his back columns by going to www.jimbrownla,.com.  You will also see a number of relevant videos and current updates on this website.

5 Responses
  1. Jim

    Out of all people I suspect you have more sense than this. What is the most obvious reason that Bobby is not running for President?

    He can’t do it. All signes show that he running for Governor. How in the world can he can run for Governor and for the GOP primary at the same time. He just can’t show up in IOWA, New Hampshire, and Sotuh Carolina In November and win a few precious months later. THey are very retail politics oriented states.

    I disagree with your analysis of Jindal by the way but that is another issue

    Bobby is wise to wait till the end of his likely second term

  2. Terry

    What a silly column. Remember the ’88 Democrat National Convention? Who was that young, southern governor who was basically booed off the stage during his speech? Oh yeah, 4 years later he became the 42nd President of the United States.

    I am not saying Bobby Jindal has made himself into presidential material yet, and I actually doubt he could make a credible run in 2012. What I am saying is that the belief that one bad speech seen by a few million hardcore political junkies would “permanently sideline” a 38 year old Rhodes Scholar/DHH Secretary/University President/Presidential Appointee/Congressman/Governor with limitless ambition is absurd.

    Instead of one bad speech, if you want to talk about what could cause someone to be “permanently sidelined” in Republican presidential politics, start with those who have ran for the nomination and lost (like Ronald Regan or George HW Bush), and especially those who got the nomination and lost the general (like Richard Nixon).

    Clearly, the GOP electorate has no “one strike, your out rule”. It’s what gives me great hope that we will see Mitt Romney sworn in as the 45th President in 2012 and how I know to ignore those who are already writing Bobby Jindal’s political obituary.

  3. Guest1085

    As a Hoosier and Governor Daniels supporter, I am always glad to see him receive much deserved national media attention. However, Governor Daniels has always maintained he would never run for another office, even going back to last fall- see: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mC9WmB1PNVM- and has never wanted to ascend to the top-tier.

    Thank you for recognizing our state and governor and for the insightful article.

  4. Pat

    Jim, Excellent Column.
    Anybody thinking about running for President should produce significant results in his/her Home State first, I would think.

    There is no doubt Gov. Bobby Jindal has the where-with-all…the “Package” to do it…here in Louisiana. The Question is: Will He? Eventually, and most people think the questions are coming soon… “What has Gov. Jindal produced in nearly 2 years?”

    You know…the meat and potatoes. Show Us The Beef!

    And if Gov. Jindal gets another opportunity to “resurrect” his National Ambitions on a National Stage…he would be best advised to come across as who he is: “A Fast Talking, Fast Thinking… Go-Getter”.

    Jindal is best unscripted….just wing it.

    He’s always been well-versed, but when he slows down…too much… he won’t (and didn’t) come across well.

    I wish Gov. Jindal the best.

    Where’s the Beef?


Leave a Reply